Strong Defense For Trial

Full Conversation

Is it good if my lawyer said if we go to trial he thinks I’ll be aquitted
Hello ****, it's generally positive if your lawyer believes in your case's strength. However, remember trial outcomes can be unpredictable. Could you share where you're located and the nature of your case to provide more specific information?
Nj
Hello ****, it's good to know you're in NJ. If your lawyer believes you have a strong case, it's generally positive. However, be aware that:
- Trial outcomes are unpredictable.
- Each case is unique and depends on its individual facts.
- Your lawyer's belief doesn't guarantee an acquittal.
Remember to keep open communication with your lawyer for the best possible outcome.
I was driving * mph and another driver made an illegal turn over * sets of double yellow lines spaced * or more feet apart in front of me and passed away
It's a complex situation, ****. In NJ, both excessive speed and illegal turns are traffic violations. The outcome depends on factors like evidence, witnesses, etc. Always discuss these with your lawyer for better understanding.
Since it’s an illegal turn did that cause the accident
Determining liability in an accident involves many factors. In NJ:
- Both your excessive speed and the other driver's illegal turn can contribute to the accident.
- Comparative negligence might apply, potentially assigning a percentage of fault to each party.
Discuss these nuances with your lawyer.
Is there comparative negligence in criminal court
Comparative negligence is typically employed in civil cases, not criminal. In criminal cases, the prosecution must prove the defendant's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Discuss your situation with your lawyer for better understanding.
If both drivers are at fault how can they prove beyond a reasonable doubt I caused it
In a criminal case, the prosecution has to prove your guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Factors considered include:
- Your excessive speed
- The circumstances of the other driver's illegal turn
- Witness testimonies
- Physical evidence at the scene
Discuss these with your lawyer to prepare your defense.
What does beyond a reasonable doubt mean
"Beyond a reasonable doubt" is a legal standard in criminal cases. It requires the prosecution to prove that there's no other logical explanation, based on the evidence, that the defendant committed the crime. It's the highest level of proof required in law.
So the illegal turn is a logical explanation
The illegal turn could be a contributing factor to the accident. However, your excessive speed might also be considered. The court will examine all evidence to determine if the prosecution has proved your guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Consult your lawyer for personalized advice.
If both are contributing factors how do you decide who’s at fault
In New Jersey, fault is often determined by:
- Examining all evidence
- Evaluating witness testimonies
- Considering the nature of traffic violations
Remember, both your excessive speed and the other driver's illegal turn could contribute to the accident. Consult with your lawyer for further guidance.
Can you get a conviction for contributing factor
In New Jersey, a conviction depends on proving guilt "beyond a reasonable doubt". Even if you're a contributing factor, it doesn't automatically mean conviction. Factors include:
- Nature of violation
- Evidence
- Witness testimonies
Discuss this with your lawyer for a comprehensive understanding.
Is speeding a contributing factor
Yes, in New Jersey and generally, speeding can be considered a contributing factor in an accident. It can be used as evidence to establish reckless or negligent behavior. However, it's important to discuss these specifics with your lawyer.
But the recklessness has to be the cause of the accident right?
In New Jersey, reckless behavior like speeding can be considered a cause of an accident. However, a court would consider all factors, like the other driver's actions, to determine the primary cause. Discuss this matter further with your lawyer.
Does speeding justify the illegal turn?
In New Jersey, neither speeding nor an illegal turn justifies the other. Both are considered traffic violations. However, how these factors contribute to the accident and liability will be evaluated separately. It's crucial to discuss your case specifics with your lawyer.
The engineer I hired said I’m not at fault because there was a jug handle that legally should have been used
That's interesting, ****. Engineers can provide critical insight into the circumstances of an accident. Can you share more about how the jug handle was supposed to be used in this context according to your engineer?
You can’t turn over * sets of double yellow lines, westbound drivers have access to use a jug handle to get to the other side of the road
Thank you for explaining, ****. In New Jersey, turning over double yellow lines is indeed illegal, and the jug handle should have been used. However, your speed might still be considered. Have you discussed this new information with your lawyer yet?
Yes he said he think I’d be aquitted at trial
It's good to hear your lawyer is confident. Remember, trials can be unpredictable, the court will consider all evidence, laws, and circumstances. A positive outlook from your lawyer is beneficial, but it doesn't guarantee an outcome. Stay in close contact with your lawyer throughout the process.
We have an engineer and precedent stating I’m not at fault
That's a strong point in your favor, ****. The expert opinion and precedent can be crucial in your defense. However, remember that the final decision lies with the court. It's great you're working closely with your lawyer and using all available resources for your case.
How much does an expert opinion mean at trial
In a trial, an expert opinion is highly valuable. It can:
- Provide clarity on complex technical details.
- Strengthen your case by supporting your claims.
- Influence the court's understanding of the facts.

Remember, it's ultimately up to the judge or jury to weigh the evidence.
Do base decisions more on experts or regular witnesses
In a trial, both expert and non-expert witnesses can play crucial roles. The weight given can depend on:
- Relevance of the testimony
- Credibility of the witness
- Consistency with other evidence
Each case can vary, and it's ultimately up to the judge or jury to decide.
Is an expert better then a witness
Both expert and non-expert witnesses are valuable and serve different purposes in a trial. Expert witnesses provide detailed insight and analysis on complex issues, while non-expert witnesses can provide first-hand accounts of events. The court will consider the credibility and relevance of both types of testimonies.
How does my case look to you
As a legal information service, I can't predict outcomes, but I can tell you that expert opinions and precedents can significantly influence a case. Your lawyer's confidence is also a good sign. Maintain open communication with your lawyer and prepare thoroughly for your trial.
Do you think I have a good defense
Based on the information you've provided, it seems you have key elements for a defense: expert opinion, precedent, and a confident lawyer. However, predicting outcomes is challenging as they depend on multiple factors including how the court evaluates all evidence. Discuss your defense strategy with your lawyer.
Is it good my lawyer is saying this after previously being a prosecutor
Yes, it's generally positive. A lawyer with experience as a prosecutor understands both sides of a case. This can provide a unique perspective and potentially stronger defense strategy. However, outcomes can't be guaranteed. It's important to trust your lawyer and maintain open communication.
Could the charges be dropped due to causation issues?
In New Jersey, charges could potentially be dropped if there are significant issues with causation. However, this depends on:
- Strength of your defense, including expert testimony
- How the court interprets the evidence
- Prosecution's ability to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
Discuss this potential with your lawyer.
With the expert and precedent could it be dropped?
It's possible that the charges could be dropped, given the strength of your defense with expert testimony and relevant precedent. However, the final decision rests with the court. It's crucial to keep in close consultation with your lawyer to navigate this process effectively.
It seems like my defense is a lot stronger then the prosecutors
Indeed, it sounds like your defense is well-prepared with expert opinion and relevant precedent. However, remember that the court's decision depends on a comprehensive evaluation of all evidence, laws, and circumstances. Please continue discussing your case with your lawyer for personalized advice.
Due prosecutors want to go to trial when the defense is stronger then what they have
In general, prosecutors evaluate the strength of their case before deciding to proceed to trial. If they believe the defense is stronger, they may consider plea negotiations or even dismissal. However, every situation varies, and it ultimately depends on the specifics of the case.
How could I have expected someone to make an illegal turn in front of me
Predicting someone's illegal actions on the road is indeed challenging. In a legal context, the court will consider factors like your reaction, speed, and the circumstances of the turn. It's crucial to discuss this question with your lawyer as it may be relevant in arguing your case.
How can I be in trouble for someone else’s illegal actions
In New Jersey, being involved in an accident where illegal actions were taken by another party doesn't automatically absolve you of responsibility. Factors considered include:
- Your speed at the time of the accident
- Your ability to react appropriately
- The circumstances of the other party's illegal action
Consult your lawyer for a clearer understanding.
All I did wrong was speeding
Indeed, ****. Speeding can be considered a violation and potentially contribute to an accident under New Jersey law. However, in your case, the other driver's illegal turn and your expert's opinion may impact the court's decision. Have you discussed how the court might view your speeding in this context with your lawyer?
Well my speed would be considered reckless, but the recklessness did not cause the accident
In New Jersey, reckless driving like speeding can be considered in determining accident liability. However, if the accident wasn't directly caused by your speeding, that could influence the court's decision. It's important to discuss this with your lawyer, who can argue that your speed wasn't the primary cause of the accident.
The only reason the accident happened was the illegal turn, if he used the jug handle like you’re legally supposed to there would be no accident right?
That's a critical point, ****. In New Jersey, correct usage of the jug handle can indeed prevent accidents. However, the court will consider all factors including your speed. Have you explored how this argument could be used in your defense with your lawyer?
Yes
That's good, ****. Keeping open communication with your lawyer and discussing all potential arguments is crucial. Remember, while your lawyer's confidence and your strong evidence are beneficial, court outcomes can be unpredictable. Continue preparing thoroughly for your trial.
Do you think an squirrel is posdible
I'm sorry, ****. Could you please provide more context or clarify your question about a squirrel?
Do you think an acquittal is possible
Based on the information you've provided, it appears you have a strong defense. However, it's important to remember that court outcomes are unpredictable and depend on a variety of factors, including how the evidence is interpreted. Continue discussing your case with your lawyer.
The lawyer said I could have been doing *, *, or * mph, if the guy used the jug handle there would be no accident, is that correct
Yes, your lawyer's argument is that the other driver's illegal turn, not your speed, caused the accident. In New Jersey, the court will consider this alongside other evidence. Remember, while this argument is strong, the court's decision will depend on a thorough evaluation of all factors.
The engineer said the same thing
That's encouraging, ****. An engineer's expert opinion can significantly bolster your defense. It's great that both your lawyer and engineer have similar views. However, it's important to remember that court outcomes rely on the comprehensive evaluation of all factors. Continue to work closely with your lawyer.