Probable Cause Traffic Stop

Summary

Probable cause in Alabama requires a reasonable belief that a crime has been committed. Being the car owner can link you to items found, but the location of items, such as in a box in the back seat, can complicate direct association. A lie can contribute to probable cause if it leads police to reasonably believe a crime occurred. An officers belief, even if mistaken, can still be considered probable cause if it was reasonable at the time. Consider consulting a local attorney for a detailed assessment of your case.

Full Conversation

I need help understanding if there was probable cause in mycase
Hi ****, can you provide more details about the situation that led to the probable cause question? Specifically, what were the circumstances of your encounter with law enforcement?
I was a passenger in a car that i owned. We were pulled over and the driver lied and told the police that he ate some fentanyl and they transported him to the hospital. When he arrived at the hospital he left before they took him inside. So, there is no record of him at the hospital. I was charged with all of his paraphenalia, drugs and possesion of a forged instrument because i owned the car.
Hi ****,
Understanding probable cause is essential in your case.
- **Probable Cause**: The police must have a reasonable belief that a crime has been committed.
- **Ownership**: Being the car owner can link you to the items found.
- **Location**: Where were the items found in the car?
Do you have any evidence or witnesses to support your account?
In a box in a the back seat
Hi ****,
Thank you for the additional details. Here are some general points regarding probable cause in Alabama:
- **Probable Cause**: Police need a reasonable basis for believing a crime was committed.
- **Ownership**: Owning the car can link you to items found.
- **Item Location**: Items in a box in the back seat can complicate the direct association.
If the items were not in your immediate possession, this might impact the case. Consider consulting with a local attorney for a detailed assessment.
can a lie give the police probable cause
Hi ****,
In Alabama, probable cause requires a reasonable belief that a crime has been committed. A lie can contribute to probable cause if it leads police to reasonably believe a crime occurred. However, this depends on the overall context.
Consider consulting an attorney for detailed advice.
Is there anything else you need help with?
the officer said he had probable cause when he thought he saw a piece of burnt foil but it actually was a food item wrapped in foil. is that still probable cause.
Hi ****,
In Alabama, probable cause is based on what the officer reasonably believed at the time, not what the item actually turned out to be. If the officer reasonably thought the foil was drug-related, it might still be considered probable cause.
Is there anything else you need help with?