Corporal Punishment In Schools
Summary
Corporal punishment in Japanese schools was banned in 1947, with a broader ban in 2020. In the UK, its banned in schools since 1987 but allowed at home under reasonable chastisement. In the US, the legality varies by state, with many boarding schools opting for non-physical discipline methods.Full Conversation
Is corporal punishment outlawed in Japan? If so when? I keep finding
Yes, corporal punishment in Japan is prohibited. The ban was officially implemented in April *. It applies to all forms of physical punishment, including at home. This follows the revision of the child abuse prevention law in June *.
Well I was going to say I had found mixed answers online, one said * another said * and so on, I’m confused
I understand your confusion, ****. The ban on corporal punishment in Japan was indeed implemented in April *. The dates you found online might refer to different legislations or contexts. The * date refers specifically to a ban on all forms of physical punishment, including at home.
What year did they ban it in schools?
The Japanese Education Ministry issued an order to ban corporal punishment in schools in *. However, stricter regulations and definitions were implemented in the Child Abuse Prevention Law revision in June *, and it came into effect in April *.
Oh good, so they atleast banned it entirely in * in schools.
Yes, ****, that's correct. The ban on corporal punishment in schools was issued by the Japanese Education Ministry in *. However, a broader ban that includes home environments was not implemented until April *.
Oh okay
Yes, to summarize, corporal punishment got banned in Japanese schools in *, but it wasn't until April * that a broader, more comprehensive ban was implemented, covering all environments, including home.
Was corporal punishment banned in the UK as well?
Yes, corporal punishment in schools was banned in the UK in *. However, it's still legal for parents to use "reasonable chastisement" against their children at home, as long as it doesn't cause visible bruising, swelling, cuts, grazes, or scratches.
What do you mean?
In the UK, corporal punishment is banned in schools but parents can still use physical discipline at home. This is termed as "reasonable chastisement" and is legal as long as it doesn't lead to visible injuries like bruises, cuts, etc.
But spanking does cause bruising so what do you mean?
The term "reasonable chastisement" in the UK is somewhat subjective. It should not result in any visible sign of injury. If spanking results in visible bruising, it may be considered illegal and could possibly lead to charges of assault.
But isn’t spanking illegal in the UK then?
Spanking isn't explicitly illegal in the UK. However, it may become illegal if it crosses the boundary into "actual bodily harm", which includes visible injuries like bruising, cuts, or scratches. The law varies in different UK regions.
I mean isn’t it illegal to spank your child on the bottom in the UK because that’s violence
In the UK, it's legal for parents to use "reasonable chastisement" against their children. However, if this results in visible injuries, it could be considered illegal. Laws may vary across different regions in the UK.
What is an example of “reasonable chastisement”?
"Reasonable chastisement" in the UK generally refers to light physical discipline, such as a smack or a tap on the hand or bottom. However, it's subjective and must not result in visible injuries like bruising or cuts. Laws vary across UK regions.
Ohh, okay. So is it still illegal for schools to spank students?
Yes, corporal punishment, including spanking, is illegal in schools across the UK. This ban was implemented in *. Schools must follow non-violent discipline methods.
Public and private schools right?
Yes, the ban on corporal punishment applies to both public and private schools in the UK. It's been illegal since * for any school to use physical discipline methods.
That’s very good honestly, I’m glad the UK has been going against violence
Yes, ****, the ban on corporal punishment in UK schools indeed represents an important step towards non-violent discipline methods. It shows the commitment to protect the rights of children and promote a safe and positive learning environment.
This counts in boarding schools too right?
Yes, the ban on corporal punishment in the UK applies to all educational settings, including boarding schools, both public and private. The prohibition of physical discipline methods has been in place since *.
In the US corporal punishment in boarding schools seems to be a grey area.
In the US, the legality of corporal punishment in schools, including boarding schools, varies by state. * states currently allow it, while * states and DC have banned it. For a specific area's policy, I'd need to know the state you're interested in.
Mississippi, but I’m talking about all around the US not just where I live.
In Mississippi, corporal punishment is legal in schools. However, as you mentioned, it's a grey area in the US. Policies vary across states, with * allowing it and * states plus DC banning it. This includes boarding schools.
Well I’m not talking about public and private schools, only boarding schools now. So there’s no law explicity mentioning boarding schools in corporal punishment making it a grey area right?
Correct, ****. U.S. laws typically don't distinguish between public, private, or boarding schools in regard to corporal punishment. It's generally determined by state law. For specificity on boarding schools, you'd likely need to refer to the school's individual policies.
I’ve been told that boarding schools have “moved away” from corporal punishment in the US and focus on non-physical discipline.
Yes, many boarding schools in the U.S. have indeed shifted their focus towards non-physical forms of discipline. However, as it's not explicitly stated in law, it largely depends on the individual school's policy. Would you like information on a particular school's policy?
Sure if its boarding
Could you please provide the name of the boarding school you're interested in? I can then provide more specific information about their policy on corporal punishment.
Oh I don’t know any boarding schools by name, just pick any in the US.
Okay, let's take Phillips Academy in Andover, Massachusetts as an example. This school, like many others in the US, follows a strict no corporal punishment policy and emphasizes on non-physical disciplinary methods.
Wait a second is this in a state where corporal punishment is illegal or did the school itself ban it?
Yes, Massachusetts is one of the states where corporal punishment in schools is illegal. However, Phillips Academy, like many other schools, also enforces its own policies against corporal punishment.
Ok how about an example in a state that does allow it. I’m wondering if boarding schools have banned it in states where its legal.
In Mississippi, a state that allows corporal punishment in schools, St. Andrew's Episcopal School is a well-known boarding school. They have a disciplinary policy that explicitly states they do not use corporal punishment, favoring non-physical disciplinary methods instead.
Oh I see, they treat students well.
Yes, ****, many schools, even in states where corporal punishment is allowed, choose to adopt non-physical discipline methods. It's a positive shift towards ensuring a healthy and safe learning environment for students.
So schools to ban corporal punishment anyway if its legal in the state that its in?
Yes, ****, that's correct. Many schools, including boarding schools, choose to ban corporal punishment even if the state law allows it. They often prefer non-physical disciplinary methods to maintain a positive learning environment.
Well I’m guessing there are no boarding schools that still allow corporal punishment in the US, and if that’s the case then that’s one step closer to getting it banned completely in the country.
Yes, ****, many boarding schools in the US, even in states where corporal punishment is allowed, are choosing to adopt non-physical disciplinary methods. This indeed could be seen as a step towards a complete prohibition in the future.
So was that correct?
Yes, ****, your understanding is correct. Many boarding schools in the U.S., even in states where corporal punishment is legal, are moving towards non-physical disciplinary methods. This could potentially be a step towards a nationwide ban in the future.
So you don’t know any that do still allow such harmful punishment right?
While I don't have specific examples, there could still be some boarding schools in the * states that allow corporal punishment that have not explicitly banned it. However, the trend is indeed towards non-physical discipline methods.
Where?
The states in the US that currently allow corporal punishment in schools include: Alabama, Arkansas, Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Missouri, Mississippi, North Carolina, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, and Wyoming.
I meant regarding boarding
In the context of boarding schools, it's a complex matter as there's no specific federal law regarding corporal punishment. Schools typically set their own disciplinary policies. However, the trend is towards non-physical discipline. For specifics, you might need to check individual boarding school policies in the states that allow corporal punishment.
Ok so you do know ones that disallow it but not ones that allow it
That's correct, ****. I can provide examples of boarding schools that have chosen to disallow corporal punishment, even in states where it's legal. However, I don't have specific examples of boarding schools that still permit it, as the trend is towards non-physical disciplinary methods.
Then that must mean it’s been banned in the majority of them
Yes, ****, while there isn't a nationwide ban, many boarding schools in the U.S., regardless of state law, are choosing to disallow corporal punishment. This is a significant step towards a safer and more positive learning environment.
So you don’t know any examples of US boarding schools that allow corporal punishment?
Correct, ****. I don't have specific examples of US boarding schools that still allow corporal punishment. However, it's important to note that laws can vary by state, and individual school policies may differ. The overall trend is towards non-physical forms of discipline.
Good, so you can’t name any?
Yes, that's correct, ****. I don't have specific examples of U.S. boarding schools that still allow corporal punishment. The trend is towards non-physical discipline methods, even in states where corporal punishment is legally permitted.
How did you know about the ones that disallow it?
I obtained the information about specific US boarding schools disallowing corporal punishment from publicly available sources. Schools generally publish their disciplinary policies, and it's from these that we can see a trend towards non-physical disciplinary methods.