Contractor Refuses To Close Insurance Claim

Summary

Contractor refuses to close an insurance claim, seeking legal advice on how to proceed. Both parties involved in an insurance claim should agree to close it. Review the contract and consider seeking an independent assessment of the damage. Consulting with a local attorney can provide personalized advice.

Full Conversation

A insurance claim has been closed. The contractor refuses to close the claim.
What state are you located in, ****? This will help me provide you with the most accurate information.
il
What is the reason given by the contractor for not closing the claim?
that he still pursuing more approval. I look at my insurance app and nothing is pending. He was approved for a certain amount but he wants more.
Has the contractor provided any written communication or contract stating the need for additional approval? In Illinois, contractors must provide a written contract for home repair or remodeling work over $*,*.
the insurance adjuster came and only approved * and the claim was closed. I asked him to close out the claim and he doesn’t want to. I want know is there anyway I can close that claim and contract legally?
What does your contract with the contractor state about termination or closure of the claim? This will help determine your legal options.
It says I can cancel 5 days after it’s signed but other than that we’re else can I see.
What is the exact wording of the cancellation clause in your contract? This will help determine your legal options. In Illinois, contracts often have specific termination clauses.
*% of payment if I should not want there services. My question is if that claim was closed, that should end the contract right? He right ought told me that the roof is worth between * and * thousand. It wasn’t approved.
What is the exact wording of the termination clause in your contract? This will help determine your legal options. In Illinois, contracts often have specific termination clauses.
on what section can I see that?
The termination clause is usually found in the latter part of the contract. It outlines the conditions under which the contract can be ended.
can u give me second to pull it out!
Of course, take your time. It's important to understand the terms of your contract to navigate this situation effectively.
It doesn’t haven’t have anything about contract termination.
What actions have you taken so far to resolve this issue with the contractor?
I sent him what was approved and asked to close it. He said no.
What is the name of the insurance company you are dealing with?
I’m looking for legal advice right. Is there anyway I can send a copy of the contract. There’s probably something I don’t understand.
Sure, you can send a copy of the contract. However, please redact any personal information for privacy reasons.
how would I do that.
You can redact personal information from a document by using a black marker or a digital tool like Adobe Acrobat's "Redact" feature. Then, you can scan or take a clear photo to send.
So what do I cross out?
You should redact any personal information such as your full name, address, phone number, email, and any financial information like bank account or credit card numbers.
Can u give a minute
Of course, take your time. We're here to help you navigate this situation.
Is there an email I can send this to?
I'm sorry, but as a chat-based service, we don't provide email support. Can I assist you further here?
Can I send it later on today because I’m working right now and my lunch break is almost over.
Of course, feel free to reach out whenever you're available. We're here to assist you */*.
i will log on again after work I get home around *:15pm
Sure, we'll be here to assist you. Feel free to log in at your convenience.
thank you do u want me to cross out the contractor company name as well?
Are you planning to share a document with us? If so, it's not necessary to cross out the contractor company name unless you prefer to for privacy reasons.
yes for your advice.
What type of document are you planning to share? Please note that while we can provide general advice, we cannot act as your attorney or provide specific legal advice.
the contract and the insurance were it states that the claim was closed.
What is the specific issue you're facing with the closed insurance claim and the contract?
i want the contract and the claim close by the contractor. He doesn’t want to close it. He says that he submitted more. I asked him to send me of what he resubmitted and doesn’t want to. I look at my insurance app and nothing was submitted and nothing is pending.
What state are you in? This will help me provide you with the most accurate information regarding contract and insurance claim laws in your area.
il
What is the nature of the contract between you and the contractor?
just by phone and through text.
Did you have any written agreement or terms discussed over the phone or text with the contractor?
Just the contract
What are the terms of the contract regarding the closure of the project and the insurance claim?
there is nothing about that.
What actions have you taken so far to resolve this issue with the contractor?
i texted him about giving me copies of what he has resubmitted and to close out the claim. I don’t want him coming to my house every time there’s a storm.
What is the contractor's response to your request for copies of the resubmitted documents and closing the claim?
He tells me that the insurance is always going to say it’s closed. He doesn’t want to give me a copy.
What is the name of your insurance company? This information can help us provide you with more specific advice.
American family. I talked to them like a week and */* ago. Then I received an email stating that if I have a question for them, I would have contact the contractor and that the contractor would forward the question to them.
What does your contract with the contractor state about communication with the insurance company?
it says that they’re representing me. I feel that they’re not. It’s all about greed right now.
What does your contract state about the termination of the contractor's services?
i will send u details later on today.
Sure, take your time. When you're ready, could you please provide the details about the termination clause in your contract?
i will provide everything
What is the exact wording of the termination clause in your contract with the contractor?
give me second
Sure, take your time. We're here to assist you when you're ready.
Property insurance policies obligate he insured to present a claim to his or her insurance company for consideration. There are * types of adjusters that could be involved in that process. The definitions of the * types are as follows: (A) "Company adjuster" means the insurance adjusters who are employees of an insurance company. They represent the interest of the insurance company and are paid by the insurance company. They will not charge you afee. (B) "Independent adjuster" means the insurance adjusters who are hired on a contract basis by an insurance company to represent the insurance companies' interest in the settlement of the claim. They are paid by your insurance company. They will not charge you afee. (C) "Public adjuster" means the insurance adjusters do not work for any insurance company. They work for the insured to assist in the preparation, presentation and settlement of the claim. The insured hires them by signing a contract agreeing to pay them a fee or commission based on a percentage of the settlement, or other method ofcompensation. FIRE DAMAGE REPRESENTATION ACT DISCLOSURE Business Transactions (* ILCS *) Fire Damage Representation Agreement Act. (* ILCS */*.*) (from Ch. *, par. *) Sec. *.* Short title. This act may be cited as the Fire Damage Representation Agreement Act. (Source: P.A. *-*.) (* ILCS */*) (from Ch. *, par. *) Sec. *. Any person who, within 5 days after a fire, makes an agreement with any other person to represent him in his claim for damages caused by that fire may, within a *-day period after the execution of such agreement, elect to avoid the agreement by notifying the other person in writing of the election by registered or certified mail, return receipt requested. The person undertaking the representation of the claimant by such an agreement must, at the time of the agreement, furnish the party with whom the agreement is made a copy of the agreement and the address to which the notice may be sent and a copy of this Act, and obtain written acknowledgement of receipt of such from the party represented. If he fails to do so, the *-day period provided for in this Act does not commence to run until the agreement, address and a copy of this Act are furnished. (Source: P.A. *-*; *-*.) WRITTEN NOTICE OF CONSUMER RIGHTS In addition to any protections granted to you the insured under the Public Adjusters Law, as a consumer of services under Illinois law you are entitled to the full protections granted by the consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act, * ILCS * et seg, including the right to bring an action for actual damages as a result of a violation of suchact. A public adjuster shall provide the insured a written disclosure concerning any direct or indirect financial interest that the public adjuster has with any other party who is involved in any aspect of the claim, other than salary, fee, commission, or other consideration established in the written contract with the insured, including but not limited to, any ownership of or auy compensation expected to be received from, any construction firm, salvage firm, building appraisal firm, board-up company, or any other firm that provides estimates for work, or that performs any work, in conjunction with damages caused by the insured loss on which the public adjuster is engaged. The word "firm" shall include any corporation, partnership, association, joint-stock, or person. Date and Time *-*-* *:* P.M.
What is the specific issue you're facing with your property insurance claim?
i just sent the disclosure.
What part of the disclosure process are you having trouble with or need clarification on?
if the claim was closed by the insurance company. The contractor should close it as well and contract should be close as well.
What state are you located in? The rules for closing an insurance claim can vary by state.
il
What is the reason given by the contractor for not closing the claim?

In Illinois, both parties involved in an insurance claim should agree to close it. If not, you may need legal assistance.
that there still waiting on approval, and on my insurance app there’s nothing else pending
What type of approval is the contractor waiting for? In Illinois, if a claim is closed by the insurance company, the contractor should also close it unless there are pending approvals.
For the roof to be replaced.
What is the reason given by the insurance company for not approving the roof replacement?
it’s not damaged to the degree that it has to be replaced.
What evidence or documentation did the insurance company provide to support their decision that the roof doesn't need to be replaced?
they had there adjuster there as well
What was the conclusion of the adjuster's assessment?
He is not satisfied.
What specific aspects of the adjuster's assessment is the contractor not satisfied with?
it’s all about greed right now. He was approved for a certain amount but he wants more.
What steps have you taken to resolve this dispute with the contractor?
i told him to close it.
What was the contractor's response when you asked him to close the claim?
No
What is the name of your insurance company and the contractor?
american family insurance
What is the exact amount that the contractor is asking for, and how does it compare to the amount approved by the insurance company?
he got approved * for the gutters and from that amount * are for minor repairs on the roof.
What is the contractor's justification for asking for more than the approved amount?
That roof is damaged and has to be replaced.
What evidence or documentation does the contractor have to support his claim that the roof needs to be replaced?
he says he has pictures. The insurance adjuster was with him while he was inspecting the roof.
What does the insurance adjuster say about the pictures and the contractor's claim that the roof needs to be replaced?
i would imagine he reported everything to the insurance. And telling them what needs to be replaced
Have you seen the pictures and do they clearly show significant damage to the roof?
nope
Have you requested to see the pictures from the contractor to assess the damage yourself?
the house is still pretty new.
Have you had an independent assessment of the roof damage to compare with the contractor's claim?
nope
Have you considered getting an independent assessment of the roof damage for a second opinion?
even though I have a signed contract am I able to do that?
Yes, you can seek an independent assessment. However, it's important to review your contract to ensure there are no clauses preventing this.
How long is a contractor contract valid for?
The validity of a contractor contract depends on the terms specified within it. Can you provide more details about the contract?
it doesn’t have an end date.
What state are you in? The rules for open-ended contracts can vary by location.
il
In Illinois, a contract remains valid until the obligations are fulfilled. However, it's best to consult a local attorney for specific advice.
How much do they charge?
Attorney fees can vary greatly depending on the complexity of the case and the attorney's experience. It's best to contact a few local attorneys for a consultation.
the * number you gave me what’s it for?
The * number I provided is for the Illinois State Bar Association. They can help you find a local attorney for a consultation.