Neighbors Tree Responsibility

Summary

In England, if a neighbors tree falls into your garden but remains rooted on their property, they are responsible for its removal. Discuss the issue amicably with your neighbor, and consider mediation if needed. Removing a shrub from your own garden is typically not a legal issue, but maintaining communication with your neighbor is advisable.

Full Conversation

No damage.
It seems like your neighbour would be responsible for clearing the tree since it's still rooted on their property. Since there's no damage to your garage roof, it might be best to have a friendly chat with your neighbour to resolve the situation. Have you discussed this with them yet?
Yes. They suggested I claim for it on my insurance.
It sounds like your neighbour is not taking responsibility. Since the tree is still rooted on their property, they should handle its removal. You might want to remind them of this and suggest discussing the issue amicably. If needed, consider mediation services to help resolve the matter.
The same neighbour is now angry with me for removing a shrub from my front garden. It was near the boundary with hers, but clearly in my garden. Is this a legal issue?
Case Rating: *
It’s generally not a legal issue if you remove a shrub from your own garden, even if it’s near a boundary. However, it's always best to maintain clear communication with your neighbour to avoid misunderstandings. Have you had a conversation with your neighbour about this matter?
She shouted at me!
Case Rating: *
It sounds like a misunderstanding that escalated. While removing a shrub from your garden is within your rights, maintaining communication with your neighbour is key. If the situation worsens or you feel threatened, consider seeking advice from local mediation services or community support.