Persistent Noise Complaint Resolution

Summary

Persistent noise disturbances in New Jersey can be addressed by documenting incidents, providing evidence to management, and considering legal action if unresolved. Management may handle the issue internally, but if the noise continues, legal recourse is an option. Police reports and audio/video evidence can strengthen your case in court. If management files a complaint, you might need to appear in court. The judge can order an eviction, but relocation decisions are typically up to property management.

Full Conversation

Neighbor still making excessive noise after notice to quit. Should I send audio and video to management still?
Hello Nicole,
You can continue providing evidence to your property management. However, local noise laws may also apply. Can you let me know your location so we can give more specific advice?
New Jersey
Hello Nicole. In New Jersey, persistent noise disturbances can be dealt with legally:
- Document incidents with date, time, and nature of noise
- Send audio and video evidence to management
- If no resolution, consider contacting a local attorney or file a claim in small claims court
Management told me I don't have to send audio or video to them
Hi Nicole,
If your management doesn't require further evidence, you may consider contacting your local authorities. Persistent noise disturbances can be a violation of local noise ordinance laws in New Jersey. In severe cases, you might also consider legal action.
So do you think management has enough evidence which is why they don't want anymore videos/audio?
Hello Nicole, it's possible that management feels they have enough evidence already. However, they may also be trying to manage the situation internally. It's advisable to keep documenting incidents for your records. If the issue persists, you could consider legal recourse.
Manage the situation internally means what?
"Manage the situation internally" means that the property management is handling the issue within their own organization, without involving external entities like the police or court. This could involve discussions with the noisy neighbor, issuing warnings, or other internal strategies.
So that means they're trying to save the neighbor from eviction?
Not necessarily, Nicole. They might just be trying to resolve the issue without resorting to eviction, which is usually a last resort due to its complexity and cost. They might be discussing ways for the neighbor to minimize the noise.
But I have the recordings why don't they want me to provide them
It could be that management feels they have enough evidence, or they're trying to handle the issue without escalating it further. However, keep your recordings for potential future use, especially if you decide to pursue legal action.
They told me if she doesn't leave by the beginning of march they'd then file a complaint because she continued to make noise after notice to quit violating the lease
It seems like the management is giving your neighbor a chance to correct their behavior or voluntarily leave. If the noise continues, they plan to take legal action. Hold onto your recordings in case they are needed in the future.
After disturbing the peace she should've been served with an eviction letter right
In New Jersey, eviction is a legal process. If a tenant disturbs the peace, landlords can:
- Provide a written warning
- If the behavior continues, issue a Notice to Cease, and then a Notice to Quit
- If still unresolved, file a complaint in court
Every case is different, so management's steps may vary.
They told me they'll be filing a complaint if she doesn't leave
It appears that your property management is following the standard eviction procedure in New Jersey. If the tenant doesn't leave voluntarily, the next step is for them to file a complaint in court. You should continue documenting any disturbances in case your evidence is needed in court.
I have documented a lot everytime it happens
That's good, Nicole. Continue documenting disturbances. This evidence could be crucial if the management files a complaint in court. Remember, in such cases, it's about the quality of evidence, not just quantity.
After them filing a complaint what's next
After filing a complaint, the court will set a date for a hearing. If the judge rules in favor of the property management, an eviction order will be issued. The tenant will then have a specific time to vacate the property.
Will the judge view/listen to the recordings?
Yes, in New Jersey, audio and video evidence can be presented in court. However, it's up to the judge's discretion whether to view or listen to such evidence. Always ensure that any recordings are lawfully obtained.
Will the judge view all the times I've had to call police on neighbor?
Yes, Nicole. In New Jersey, if the police were involved, the judge will likely view the police reports as evidence. It could strengthen your case. Make sure to keep all documentation related to these incidents.
Police reports and audio/video is enough to evict problematic tenant right?
Yes, Nicole. In New Jersey, police reports, audio/video evidence, and documented disturbances can be used as evidence in an eviction case. However, the decision ultimately lies with the judge. The more compelling the evidence, the higher the chance of a favorable outcome.
Will I have to be in court?
If your property management files a complaint and you're listed as a witness, you might be required to appear in court. But this depends on the specifics of the case and the court's requirements. Remember, each situation is unique.
Can the judge move me if she doesn't get kicked out?
The decision to move you would typically be up to your property management, not the judge. A judge can order an eviction, but relocating tenants within a property is usually a management decision. However, every case is unique. If the issue persists, consider seeking advice from a local attorney.
Why is she still making excessive noise if she's been given a notice to quit?
There could be several reasons for this, Nicole. They might not take the notice seriously, or they may not have a place to move to. It's also possible they disagree with the notice. Ultimately, their motivations can be diverse and complex.
But shouldn't a person be quiet instead of making noise?
Indeed, Nicole. It's generally expected that people respect their neighbors' peace and quiet. However, not everyone adheres to these norms and laws. If the noise continues, you have options, such as contacting local authorities or consulting with a local attorney.